175 Madison St
Listing Notes
175 Madison Street is a historic Sag Harbor Village home defined by rare longevity and soulful character. With only two owners in the last 90 years, this early 1800s beauty has been cherished and preserved with a level of care that's nearly impossible to find. Set on a quarter-acre deep lot in the heart of the Village, it blends historic charm with the system upgrades today's lifestyle demands. The four-bedroom, 1.5-bath interior is anchored by stunning original wide plank flooring, while a new septic system and full 2025 HVAC overhaul-with expansion potential-ready the home for the future. Outside, the grounds have been transformed into a private oasis. Mature landscaping, a sweet arbor, and a shaded pergola surround a 15' x 32' heated Gunite pool, complemented by a pool cabana and versatile studio/garage. It's a hidden escape that feels secluded, yet sits just three blocks from Main Street.
Price in context
Cheaper than 46% of the 24 homes listed nearby right now, which run $1,995,000 to $4,995,000.
See all 24 nearby listings
| Address | Asking | Size |
|---|---|---|
| 1331 Brick Kiln Rd | $1,995,000 | 3 bd · 2 ba |
| 15 Church St Unit 41 | $2,195,000 | 1 bd · 2 ba |
| 15 Church St Unit G108 | $2,195,000 | 1 bd · 2 ba |
| 25 Meadow St | $2,395,000 | 4 bd · 1 ba |
| 51 Garden St | $2,500,000 | 3 bd · 1 ba |
| 356 Main St | $2,500,000 | 4 bd · 2 ba |
| 1206 Middle Line Hwy | $2,549,000 | 4 bd · 4 ba |
| 44 Robeson Blvd | $2,895,000 | 4 bd · 4 ba |
| 1618 Sagg Rd | $2,900,000 | 3 bd · 2 ba |
| 22 Spring Ln | $3,295,000 | 4 bd · 4 ba |
| 137 Bay St | $3,300,000 | 3 bd · 2 ba |
| 338 Main St | $3,395,000 | 4 bd · 2 ba |
| 6 Joseph Francis Blvd | $3,495,000 | 5 bd · 7 ba |
| 233 Madison St | $3,595,000 | 4 bd · 3 ba |
| 18 Cuffee Dr | $3,700,000 | 5 bd · 5 ba |
| 25 Harrison St | $3,795,000 | 3 bd · 2 ba |
| 1 Carver St | $3,850,000 | 3 bd · 3 ba |
| 1215 Middle Line Hwy | $3,899,999 | 5 bd · 5 ba |
| 28 Lighthouse Ln | $4,250,000 | 6 bd · 6 ba |
| 15 Church St Unit G122 | $4,395,000 | 2 bd · 2 ba |
| 78 Round Pond Ln | $4,495,000 | 4 bd · 5 ba |
| 15 Glover St | $4,500,000 | 3 bd · 3 ba |
| 8 E Union St | $4,749,000 | 4 bd · 4 ba |
| 25 Rector St | $4,995,000 | 3 bd · 3 ba |
Where it is
For sale Coming soon Recently sold— zoom out for more
OpenRealtor, a RealtyLens company. Listing facts are drawn from public feeds and enriched with NYC public records. This is not the original listing site.