58 Firestone Rd
Listing Notes
Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 sq. ft. residence offers breathtaking water vistas and unforgettable sunsets. The first level features three bedrooms, two of which open directly onto a sheltered patio with panoramic bay views, along with a full bathroom. Upstairs, an expansive living room with a cozy wood-burning stove flows seamlessly into the dining area and fully equipped kitchen. Sliders open onto a generous wrap-around deck overlooking the water, perfect for entertaining or relaxing. The primary bedroom is also on this level with its own bath and private access to the deck, and there is an additional full bathroom on this floor for convenience. A versatile loft/office occupies the third floor, showcasing sweeping water views. Additional amenities include an attached garage for storage, an unfinished basement useful for storage, an outdoor shower, and direct water access ideal for kayaking or mooring a small boat out front. Just moments from the harbor and town center, this property is a rare Montauk retreat combining comfort, privacy, and unmatched sunsets.
Price in context
Cheaper than 29% of the 24 homes listed nearby right now, which run $2,750,000 to $6,950,000.
See all 24 nearby listings
| Address | Asking | Size |
|---|---|---|
| 46 N Shore Rd | $2,750,000 | 2 bd · 1 ba |
| 148 Fairview Ave | $2,850,000 | 3 bd · 3 ba |
| 161 Monroe Dr | $2,895,000 | 5 bd · 4 ba |
| 6 Fort Pond Ln | $2,900,000 | — |
| 14 Fairview Rd | $2,900,000 | 2 bd · 1 ba |
| 113 Duryea Ave | $2,975,000 | 6 bd · 3 ba |
| 18 Wills Point Rd | $2,995,000 | — |
| 23 Surfside Ave | $2,995,000 | 4 bd · 3 ba |
| 403 Lake Dr | $2,999,999 | — |
| 1 Capt Balfor Way | $3,200,000 | — |
| 5 N Fleming Ct | $3,200,000 | 3 bd · 4 ba |
| 1 Florida Rd | $3,485,000 | 5 bd · 6 ba |
| 205 Fairview Ave | $3,495,000 | 4 bd · 3 ba |
| 131 S Edgemere St | $3,795,000 | 5 bd · 8 ba |
| 21 Dubois Pl | $3,995,000 | 6 bd · 6 ba |
| 55 S Davis Ave | $4,495,000 | 4 bd · 4 ba |
| 15 Edgemere St | $4,699,000 | 4 bd · 4 ba |
| 10 and 14 Fairview Rd | $5,500,000 | 2 bd · 1 ba |
| 8 S Ferncroft Pl | $5,500,000 | 5 bd · 6 ba |
| 137 S Edgemere St | $5,795,000 | 7 bd · 8 ba |
| 249 Lake Dr | $5,995,000 | 3 bd · 3 ba |
| 113 S Edgemere St | $6,295,000 | 7 bd · 9 ba |
| 95 Washington Dr | $6,900,000 | 6 bd · 7 ba |
| 278 W Lake Dr | $6,950,000 | 4 bd · 4 ba |
Where it is
For sale Coming soon Recently sold— zoom out for more