727-729 Shiloh Pike
Listing Notes
This is not just a home, it's a conversation piece, a piece of local history, and a truly rare opportunity to own something unlike anything else on the market. Originally converted from a church, this beautifully renovated property has been thoughtfully transformed into a spacious and distinctive residence, NEWLY RENOVATED in 2022! From the open kitchen that was tastefully redone, to all the land that comes with the property, the home still carries the warmth, presence, and timeless charm of its original purpose while offering the comfort of a fully renovated home. Situated across two lots, the property offers approximately 2,500+ square feet of living space (including the basement that's finished) with endless flexibility for multigenerational living. Renovations completed in 2022 include updated HVAC, electrical, plumbing, kitchen, bathrooms, and more. Freshly painted in 2026. Make your appointment to see this home today!
OpenRealtor Estimate
Asking price is about 10.9% below the fair value — likely to draw competing offers if it's still on market.
Bid uses comp pricing, nearby pending/sold pressure when available, listing history, and public-record risk. Broad lifestyle heuristics are not allowed to move the number.
Where it is
For sale Coming soon Recently sold— zoom out for more