MarketsNJ
Old Tappan, NJ
Live listings and local prices in Old Tappan, refreshed Aug 4, 2026.
Listings14
Median price$2,149,450
Median $/sqft—
Mix86% sale
Listings
14 homes$2,890,000for sale
7 Orchard Ln
5 bd · 7 ba
$2,950,000for sale
2 Stewart Ct
5 bd · 7 ba · 7,600 sqft
$1,899,900for sale
1051 Westwood Ave
5 bd · 5 ba
$2,399,000for sale
27 Pine Hill Rd
6 bd · 5 ba

$815,000for sale
35 Quail Run Unit 35
2 bd · 3 ba

$2,790,000for sale
106 Koch Ln
5 bd · 5 ba

$1,789,000for sale
136 Willow Dr
4 bd · 4 ba
$2,499,000for sale
99 Ogle Rd
6 bd · 6 ba
$1,349,000for sale
6 Jay St
4 bd · 4 ba

$6,500for rent
2 Candlewood Dr
3 bd · 4 ba
$2,590,000for sale
81 Greenwoods Rd
6 bd · 5 ba

$5,290for rent
5 Little Brook Rd
3 bd · 2 ba
$3,925,000for sale
15 Stonegate
6 bd · 7 ba
$1,699,000for sale
1 Sherwood Ct
5 bd · 5 ba