MarketsNY
Shelter Island Heights, NY
Live listings and local prices in Shelter Island Heights, refreshed Aug 8, 2026.
Listings9
Median price$2,100,000
Median $/sqft$617
Mix100% sale
Listings
9 homes
$2,100,000for sale
61 Gardiners Bay Dr
6 bd · 5 ba · 4,389 sqft · $478/sqft

$3,750,000for sale
10 Point Ln
5 bd · 6 ba · 5,386 sqft · $696/sqft

$1,999,999for sale
4 Bayview Ave
6 bd · 6 ba · 6,098 sqft · $328/sqft

$4,995,000for sale
20 Prospect Ave
7 bd · 5 ba · 4,124 sqft · $1211/sqft

$4,995,000for sale
20 Prospect Ave
7 bd · 6 ba · 5,000 sqft · $999/sqft

$2,595,000for sale
11 Prospect Ave
4 bd · 3 ba · 1,994 sqft · $1301/sqft

$499,000for sale
13 Winthrop Rd Unit 24
1 bd · 1 ba · 39,964 sqft · $12/sqft

$1,500,000for sale
5 Spring Garden Ave
5 bd · 3 ba · 2,845 sqft · $527/sqft

$895,000for sale
26 New York Ave
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,450 sqft · $617/sqft